BULUS GOLIT V INSPECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE
APPEAL NO: CA/A/828C/2017
Areas Of Law:
Appeal, Constitutional Law, Courts, Criminal Law And Procedure, Jurisdiction, Law Of Evidence, Practice And Procedure, Words And Phrases.
Summary Of Fact
The Appellant together with two other co-accused were arraigned before the trial court on an amended 21 count charge of conspiracy, unlawful assembly with deadly weapon, abduction, assault, intimidation, robbery, unlawful attack, for which the Appellant and the other two co-accused persons entered a plea of not guilty.
The Appellant together with the co-accused made a no case submission. The trial court while giving its ruling on the no case submission struck out twenty (20) out of the twenty-one (21) counts against the Appellant and other Co-Accused persons.
The Appellant was found guilty of the remaining charge of unlawful conspiracy an offence punishable under Section 97 of the Penal Code Law Cap 89 of Northern Nigeria 1963, while the 1st and 2nd Co-Accused persons were discharged and acquitted by the court. Dissatisfied with the decision of the Court, which discharged and acquitted the 1st and 2nd Co- Accused persons and found the Appellant guilty and sentenced to one (1) year imprisonment, the Appellant has appealed to the Court of Appeal against the said decision of the trial court.
Held
Appeal Dismissed
Issues For Determination
Ø Was the Learned Trial Judge was right to have convicted the Appellant for the offence of conspiracy after having found as follows:
o “The real question of fact upon which the charge turns; is whether or not the accused persons agreed with and/or instigated the youths. On this score, I have carefully perused the evidence of the prosecution witness and am unable to find the existence of any express or positive agreement between the accused persons and the marauding youths”.
Ø Was the Learned trial Judge right in convicting the Appellant for the alleged offence of conspiracy after discharging and acquitting the co-accused persons of the same offence on the same facts and evidence.
Ø Is the judgment of the High Court of Kogi State not perverse and liable to be set aside for imposing a sentence of imprisonment unknown to law and far above the minimum sentence prescribed by law.
Ø Did the High Court of Kogi State possess the jurisdiction to determine the criminal charge in Charge No: HCL/65C/2015 without any element of the offence as charged occurring in Kogi State?
Rationes
OFFENCE OF CONSPIRACY- MEANING OF THE OFFENCE OF CONSPIRACY
“Conspiracy is an agreement between two or more persons to do an unlawful act; the agreement may be express or implied, and the offence of conspiracy is consummated once it is established to the satisfaction of the court, that the parties agreed to effect an unlawful act.
The offense could be a continuing process, leading others to join an existing conspiracy in stages, and become parties to it for that reason; that is why it is not necessary for all parties to a conspiracy to be in contact with each other at any particular stage the very plot is an act in itself, and the act of each of the parties promise against promise, actus contra actum, capable of being enforced if lawful, Is punishable if it is for a criminal object or the use of criminal means” per OREDOLA JCA; Akinlolu V State (2017) LPELR-42670-SC and also, Oduneye V. State (2001) 2 NWLR (Pt. 697) 311, (2001) LPELR- 2245.
What matters is that all the parties to the conspiracy have a common objective or purpose, communicated to at least one other person to the conspiracy”. PER M. MUSTAPHA, J.C.A
PROOF OF CONSPIRACY- STANDARD OF PROOF REQUIRED IN THE OFFENCE OF CONSPIRACY
“It is important like in all crimes to prove the agreement between the parties, express or inferred beyond reasonable doubt, because an inference or circumstantial evidence of an agreement suffices; see Mounwem & Ors V Queen (1963) LPELR-25406-SC, Njovens & Ors V State (1973) LPELR-2042-SC and Mv Long Island V FRN (22018)L PELR-43479-CA.” PER M. MUSTAPHA, J.C.A
EVIDENCE OF A WITNESS – DUTY OF THE COURT WHERE THERE ARE CONTRADICTING EVIDENCE IN THE WRITTEN STATEMENT AND ORAL EVIDENCE OF A WITNESS
“The law is settled that where there is a conflict between the written statement made to the police by a witness and his oral evidence in Court, the trial court ought to hold that the witness is unreliable, and his evidence cannot be relied upon; and in this case where both sets of evidence from the appellant are mutually contradictory in material particulars it is not safe for the trial Court to pick and choose which of them was reliable and which was the unreliable version of the incidence; see: Boy Muka V. The State (1976) 10 SC. 305 and Sunday V. The State (2010) 18 NWLR (pt. 1224) 223 at 241.” PER M. MUSTAPHA, J.C.A
CONTRADICTORY EVIDENCE- WHEN IS A PIECE OF EVIDENCE SAID TO BE CONTRADICTORY?
“A piece of evidence is said to contradict another when it affirms the opposite of what that other evidence has stated, and not only when there is just a minor discrepancy between the two stories; two pieces of evidence contradict one. another when they are by themselves contradictory, and therefore inconsistent; See Gabriel V. State (1989) 5 NWLR (Pt. 122) p. 457.” PER. M. MUSTAPHA. J.C.A
OFFENCE OF CONSPIRACY- FUNDAMENTAL ELEMENT OF THE OFFENCE OF CONSPIRACY
“The fundamental element of the offence of conspiracy is the agreement and association to do an unlawful act, which is forbidden by law, whether that act be criminal or not and whether or not the accused persons had knowledge of its unlawfulness. Evidence of conspiracy is usually a matter of inference from surrounding facts and circumstances of the case. It is within the trial court’s right to infer conspiracy from the fact of things done towards a common purpose, see Aje V. The State (2006) 8 NWLR (982) 345 at 363.” PER M. MUSTAPHA, J.C.A
OFFENCE OF CRIMINAL CONSPIRACY- INGREDIENTS A PROSECUTION MUST ESTABLISH TO SUSTAIN A CHARGE OF CRIMINAL CONSPIRACY
“It is very important in the matter of the offence of Criminal conspiracy leveled against the appellant, not to lose sight of the fact that to sustain the charge, the prosecution has a duty to establish the following:
- An agreement between two or more persons to do or cause to be done, some illegal act or some act which is not illegal by illegal means.
- Where the agreement is other than an agreement to commit an offence, that some acts besides the agreement was done by one or more of the parties in furtherance of the argument,
- Specifically, that each of the accused individually participated in the conspiracy.
See State V. Salawu (2010) All FWLR (Pt 614); 1 at pg. 29; Adekunle V. The State (1989) 12 SCNJ 184; 1989 5 NWLR (Pt 125) 505; Nwosu V. The State (2004) All FWLR (Pt. 218) 916; (2004) 15 NWLR (Pt 897) 466 at 486.“ PER M. MUSTAPHA, J.C.A
PROOF OF CRIMINAL CONSPIRACY- WHETHER IT IS NECESSARY FOR THE PROSECUTION TO ESTABLISH THAT THE CONSPIRATORS HAVE BEEN IN DIRECT COMMUNICATION IN PROVING THE OFFENCE OF CRIMINAL CONSPIRACY
“Having said that the prosecution does not have to prove that the conspirators met before carrying out their activities, which are seen as criminal, rather the offence of conspiracy is sustained by the prosecution leading evidence from which the Court can infer the criminal acts of the accused person, done in pursuance of the criminal purpose.
Equally important is the fact that all that is expected of the prosecution, to establish conspiracy, is to prove the rudiments of the offence, and the inference that there is a meeting of the minds of the accused persons. It is not necessary to establish that the conspirators had been in any direct communication or contact, with one another, because there is no hard and fast rule as to how to infer conspiracy; even the mere evidence of complicity is sufficient on the part of the accused appellant is sufficient; see Osondu v. F.R.N. (2000) 12 NWLR part 682 page 482 at 501-502.“ PER M. MUSTAPHA, J.C.A
OBJECTION TO A CHARGE- APPROPRIATE TIME FOR TAKING AN OBJECTION TO A CHARGE
“Learned senior counsel further contended the charge was bad for uncertainty; now even that were so, any objection to a charge for any formal defect on the face thereof or for any perceived irregularity relating to procedure, shall be taken immediately after the charge has been read over to the accused and not later; see Okaroh V. State (1990) 1 NLWR part 125, Magaji V. The Nigerian Army (2008) LPELR – 1814-SC, Okaroh V. State (1990) 1 NWLR (Pt. 125) 128 and Agbo V. State (2006) 6 NWLR (Pt. 977) 545.” PER. M. MUSTAPHA. J.C.A
PROSECUTION OF ACCUSED PERSONS – WHETHER THE PROSECUTION IS OBLIGED TO PROSECUTE OTHER ACCUSED PERSONS
“And for the avoidance of doubt, the prosecution does not have to prosecute other accused persons, even if they are available, because the choice of who to prosecute, and who not to is exclusively that of the prosecution; see Akpa V State (2008) 4-5 SC part 2 page 1.” PER. M. MUSTAPHA, J.C.A
COURT OF APPEAL- DUTY OF A COURT OF APPEAL
“This court is to determine cases on appeal on the grounds of error of law or of facts alleged, and whether the trial court has come to the right decision. It is not necessarily whether the trial Court was right in the manner the case was decided, but whether the reasons were right. This court is more concerned with correcting the errors of law or fact alleged in the decision of the trial Court; See Ukejianya v. Uchendu (1950) 13 WACA 45 at 46 and Akeredolu & Ors V Akinremi & Ors (1989) LPELR-328-SC.” PER M. MUSTAPHA, J.C.A
TERRITORIAL JURISDICTION OF A COURT- MEANING OF THE TERRITORIAL JURISDICTION OF A COURT
“Territorial jurisdiction of a court implies a geographic area within which the authority of the Court may be exercised and outside of which the Court has no power to act; every manner of Jurisdiction, territorial or otherwise, is statutory and is conferred on the Court by the law creating it; see Nigeria Alluminium Manufacturing Co Ltd & Anr V Union Bank (2015) LPELR-26010-CA.“ PER M. MUSTAPHA, J.C.A
TERRITORIAL JURISDICTION OF A COURT- NATURE OF THE TERRITORIAL JURISDICTION OF A COURT
“There is a distinction between various types of jurisdiction, i.e. extra territorial jurisdiction, territorial jurisdiction and local jurisdiction. The relevant consideration for the purposes of this judgment is territorial jurisdiction, with regard to territorial jurisdiction, a court can try any person, citizen or no-citizen who is alleged to have committed an offence in Nigeria, within the territory where the court in question has jurisdiction; the power of a court to try an accused person for an offence committed within the country is divided between the federating units. As such, one or more of the federating units may possess jurisdiction to try an accused person. The provisions of the law governing territorial jurisdiction in Nigeria, in this particular case is section 4 of the Penal Code (Northern States) Federal Provisions Act 1960.” PER M. MUSTAPHA, J.C.A
Statutes Referred To:
The Penal Code (Northern States) Federal Provisions Act 1960
The Penal Code Law Cap 89 of Northern Nigeria
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, distributed, or transmitted in any form or by any means, including photocopying, recording, or other electronic or mechanical methods, without the prior written permission of the publisher, except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical reviews and certain other noncommercial uses permitted by copyright law.
The opinions expressed except where they originate from benudechukwu.com, represent the views of such authors. BENUDECHUKWU.COM shall not be held liable for such personal views as canvassed.



